Guilt, Shame, Regret, Remorse
The undercurrents of guilt, shame, regret, and remorse run deeply and expansively in Antigone. These notions move the plot forward and twist it, complicating straightforward, black-and-white perspectives on guilt and innocence. Though these concepts have similar definitions, they are not exactly the same. Webster-Merriam defines them as follows:
GUILT: the fact of having committed a breach of conduct especially violating law and involving a penalty
SHAME: a painful emotion caused by consciousness of guilt, shortcoming, or impropriety
REGRET: sorrow aroused by circumstances beyond one’s control or power to repairREMORSE: a gnawing distress arising from a sense of guilt for past wrongs
Guilt differs from the rest of them as it refers to a state of being, rather than an emotion or feeling. A “guilty” person has been convicted in a court of law or socially of committing a wrong. Shame is the emotion associated with guilt; a person feels shame when they are conscious that they have committed a wrong that they acknowledge is a violation of their personal ethics and morals. Regret, then, is the sadness that springs forth when a person has made a choice that they would undo if they could. Remorse differs from regret in that it is a more profound, deeper feeling; the root of the word elucidates this. Remorse stems from the Latin prefix re-, returning or coming back, and mordēre, to bite. The word, then, evokes a sense of being chewed up by a past wrong—hence the description “gnawing” its Webster definition. We will examine how each of these presents itself in Antigone, paying close attention to its effects on the characters and its influence on the play’s progression.
“Shame” is uttered in the opening exchange in the play. Antigone is giving bad news to Ismene:
O Ismene, what do you think? Our two dear brothers…
Creon has given funeral honors to one,
And not to the other; nothing but shame and ignominy.
“Shame” here denotes what others feel towards someone who has committed a grievance. The fate Creon has enacted upon Polynices’ dead body has condemned him to receiving disgust from the rest of Thebes. It has solidified his legacy as defined by his final act—waging war on his homeland, Thebes. However, this is not the only thing he is shamed for, even though it is only implied; he, along with Eteocles, Antigone, and Ismene, is the son of Oedipus, the king fated to kill his father and marry his mother. Oedipus passes on his guilt to his children, as if his self-mutilating act was not penance enough.
In fact, even earlier in the play, in the third line, Antigone references this heredity of guilt.
You know how heavy the hand of God is upon us;
How we who are left must suffer for our father, Oedipus.
Her mother, too, experienced this shame by proximity. Although she knew not that Oedipus was in fact her son, her overwhelming sense of shame drove her to hang herself. Antigone and Ismene are the only ones left in the lineage of Oedipus and Jocasta, which gives Ismene pause when Antigone asks her to assist her in carrying the body of Polynices and giving him a proper burial. When she decides not to help Antigone, she says:
May the dead forgive me.
Ismene feels regret for not helping Antigone. Later on, when Antigone has been caught and sentenced to death, her regret comes to the forefront even more. She begs to die with Antigone. Though she feared the burden of guilt initially, not wanting to break the law, she does not shame Antigone, and feels no shame herself. She even proclaims
…I am not ashamed to stand beside you
Now in your hour of trial, Antigone.
There is an interesting cycle of contradiction that follows guilt. Burying the dead, according to Creon, is defying the law. Defying the law by definition makes one guilty. But when the law is against the laws of Heaven, what is Antigone to do? To save her brother’s soul and put him to rest, she must shoulder the burden of guilt in a social, legal sense, but will be upholding truer, higher laws. Anyone caught in this cycle is doomed to death.
Antigone is aware of her guilt but refuses to feel shame. She knows that she has done the right thing; nobody, not her sister, not the king, can convince her otherwise. The public’s reaction to the affair exemplifies the idea of guilt or innocence by popular vote. Most of the public, several characters say, is siding with Antigone and incensed by her sentence. Creon, however, is convinced of her wrongdoing. Because of Polynices’ treason against Thebes, Creon transfers his guilt to Antigone. How can one be guilty and innocent at the same time? Judgement is personal, the play implies, and cannot be completely trusted, especially in the hands of one person, one person with biases, grudges, and immense power.
But Creon is about to experience guilt, shame, regret, and remorse at the same time. When blind prophet Teiresias visits Creon to warn him of his misdeeds, Creon initially disregards his prophecy. But when he learns of the foretold fallout of his actions, he suddenly becomes aware of his guilt, and feels a crushing sense of blame for what he is about to learn has happened to Antigone, Creon’s son and Antigone’s betrothed Haemon, and his wife, Eurydice. Now three persons’ blood is on his hands.
In agonizing grief and unbearable shame, he asks to be led away to die.
I am nothing. I have no life.
Lead me away…
That have killed unwillingly
My son, my wife.
I know not where I should turn,
Where to look for help.
My hands have done amiss, my head is bowed
With fate too heavy for me.